sabotabby: raccoon anarchy symbol (design)
sabotabby ([personal profile] sabotabby) wrote2013-05-25 12:56 pm

It's time for another round of "well, they had good intentions"

Rather than spend money to make the city more accessible, New York City has decided to replace signage with the old accessibility symbol with a new one.

The one you've all seen:



The new one:



Er.

The major problems with this have already been pointed out in the comments, but to recap:

1. It's visually cluttered with the useless second wheel.
2. It looks like a Cubist Goatse.
3. If your posture was like that in an actual wheelchair, you would probably be falling out of it.
4. Wait, where's the back of the wheelchair?
5. It presents a patronizing view of all disabled people being inspirational wheelchair athletes or some such.

My problem is mainly #1 (hilariously ironic, considering the number of visually impaired people who will have difficulty reading it) and #5 (no matter how spunky you make your representation of disability, it still sucks to get around in a wheelchair in pretty much every place I've ever been to). It's yet another example of well-meaning people doing something to feel as though they're doing something.

By the way, there's nothing wrong with visually static icons in signage. Washroom signs (portraying able-bodied, gendered people) are pretty static looking:



(Though I vastly prefer the ones David Carson shows in this video, as they do away with silly gender essentialist norms altogether and focus on the practicalities.)

Anyway. Progress, or major headdesk moment: Discuss!
ironed_orchid: pin up girl reading kant (intellectual hottie (green))

[personal profile] ironed_orchid 2013-05-26 06:42 am (UTC)(link)
I remember seeing a post about different disability access signs, and the one the blogger liked was a sort of in between those two, like, you could see the person was self-propelling, but there wasn't the whole second wheel bit.

But the thing is that access needs to be for all sorts of people in all sorts of chairs, and some are self-propelled and some aren't.

[identity profile] kryss-labryn.livejournal.com 2013-05-26 01:26 pm (UTC)(link)
Yeah; appropriate for grandma in her motorized scooter, it is not. Hell, that thing isn't appropriate for anyone except Rick Hansen. New York does know that there are other disabled people than Rick Hansen, right?
ironed_orchid: pin up girl reading kant (intellectual hottie (green))

[personal profile] ironed_orchid 2013-05-27 01:50 am (UTC)(link)
Most of the disabled toilets here are unisex and separate from the men's and women's.